We Tried Pinterest’s High Three Fireball Pumpkin Pie Recipes

We Tried Pinterest’s Most Popular Fireball Pumpkin Pie Recipes—These Were Our Favorites

Scroll To See Extra Photographs

Pumpkin pie is a Thanksgiving staple. Annually, we look ahead to it. We cherish it. We make room for it—even when are stomachs are full from the myriad decadent dishes we devoured over the course of our Thanksgiving feast.

As a result of pumpkin pie is scrumptious. Pumpkin pie is price it.

This 12 months, enterprising Thanksgiving hosts are in search of new methods to method outdated favorites. They’re reimagining traditional Thanksgiving dishes and infusing them with new life. And everybody’s favourite pumpkin pie has gotten one thing of a taste makeover within the course of.

In keeping with our associates at Pinterest, Fireball pumpkin pie is on the menu this 12 months. And once I say “Fireball pumpkin pie,” I imply pumpkin pie infused with Fireball cinnamon whiskey. (Yup, that Fireball.) Searches for the dish are up a whopping 6,954 p.c this 12 months—so don’t be stunned while you take a chew of pumpkin pie and find yourself with severely dynamic, spicy, decadent taste.

In occasions like these, I’d often pull collectively a recipe roundup—an overarching take a look at approaches to this scrumptious development. However it might simply embrace the identical dish time and again and over once more.

As an alternative of bombarding you with each Fireball pumpkin pie recipe on Pinterest, I made a decision to take a special method: I discovered the three hottest Fireball pumpkin pie recipes on Pinterest, cooked all three variations of the pie, and introduced all three of them into the workplace for a style take a look at.

As a result of let’s be actual—you don’t must know Fireball pumpkin pie recipes exist. That you must know which one is finest. So you possibly can delight (and impress) your Thanksgiving companions with some severely scrumptious pie—and luxuriate in some, your self.

By far probably the most low-maintenance of the Fireball pumpkin pies I whipped up (it was the one one which didn’t name for home made crust), Laura Is Cooking’s tackle the dish impressed virtually everybody who tried it.

It additionally turned out prettier than the opposite two—possible as a result of the store-bought crust made for an extremely steady basis.

 We Tried Pinterests Most Popular Fireball Pumpkin Pie Recipes—These Were Our Favorites

Lindsey Lanquist.

Taste: 4.6/5
Texture: 3.6/5
Crust: 3.7/5

One coworker known as this pie a “taste bomb in my mouth.” One other known as it “good.” One wrote, “I don’t often like pumpkin (or pie, for that matter), however that is truthfully scrumptious.”

The one grievance? “Very sturdy Fireball aftertaste—would get breathalyzed.” Which is honest, contemplating this recipe known as for extra Fireball than the opposite two.

Fast observe: The recipe requires store-bought frozen pumpkin pie crust. I couldn’t discover that at my native grocery, so I went with pre-cooked gingerbread pumpkin pie crust, as an alternative. The crust bought some texture complaints, however tons of reward, flavor-wise—I truthfully suppose it would’ve despatched this pie into successful territory and would undoubtedly advocate it to anybody whipping up a Fireball pumpkin pie of their very own.

Oh, and this recipe makes two pies. I didn’t notice that and ended up with a ton of additional pie filling.

This recipe was a bit extra concerned. It known as for a home made crust (which, as you possibly can inform from the photograph, didn’t go nicely aesthetically). It additionally took a extremely, actually very long time to cook dinner—so lengthy that I ended up broiling it on the finish, which created the gorgeous charred particulars you possibly can see on the pie’s floor.

Nonetheless, it was a crowd-pleaser. Those that weren’t notably into gingerbread tended to favor this one over the primary—and it bought tons of compliments on texture.

 We Tried Pinterests Most Popular Fireball Pumpkin Pie Recipes—These Were Our Favorites

Lindsey Lanquist.

Taste: 3.4/5
Texture: 3.9/5
Crust: 3.7/5

“Clear winner. SCRUMPTIOUS,” one coworker wrote. “All-around amaze-(hearth)balls,” one other famous. Different taste-testers commented on the “creamy” texture and scrumptious “butter-filled” crust.

Whereas one taste-tester appreciated the “refined” taste (noting that the dish tasted like a “traditional pumpkin pie with slightly kick”), one other wished for one thing extra: “Greatest total, however want it was spiced extra.”

Everybody who tried the pie appeared to agree, nonetheless, that this one boasted the most effective texture—the graceful consistency that the majority resembled a traditional pumpkin pie.

(No losers right here. Every of those pies gained somebody’s coronary heart.)

Delish’s tackle Fireball pumpkin pie was noticeably completely different from the opposite two. This recipe known as for heavy cream, brown sugar, flour and vanilla extract—elements that aren’t essentially normal so far as pumpkin pies go.

The cream left the pie lighter in colour (delightfully so, I believed) and creamier in texture. Although my coworkers most well-liked the feel on the second pie, I believed this one had probably the most to supply within the consistency division.

 We Tried Pinterests Most Popular Fireball Pumpkin Pie Recipes—These Were Our Favorites

Lindsey Lanquist.

Taste: 2.7/5
Texture: 3.7/5
Crust: 3.7/5

Although many taste-testers appreciated this pie’s “fairly” look (as a slice, not an entire) and “excellent” taste, most lamented the subtlety of the dish. Many reported getting “no Fireball” from this one. (Truthful sufficient, contemplating the recipe known as for much less Fireball than the opposite two.)

This one bought tons of crust love, nonetheless. Whereas the store-bought crust from the primary pie garnered tons of taste compliments and a handful of texture complaints, this one gained on each fronts. Individuals known as the crust “moist” and “good.” One coworker even famous that it “tasted like pizza,” which she “didn’t hate.” (I’ll take it.)

One other fast observe: This was my first time making home made crust ever. Each undoubtedly turned out extremely thick (and fairly rattling ugly), however they each bought some critical compliments.

The purpose? If you wish to attempt the second or third recipes however really feel intimidated by the prospect of home made crust, don’t fear about it. No matter you make is bound to return out splendidly, and if it doesn’t, store-bought crust is at all times an possibility.

The Verdict?

For those who’re a gingerbread lover, go for the primary pie (however be sure that your store-bought crust is gingerbready). For those who’d favor a subtler spin on the standard pumpkin pie, attempt the second. And in the event you’re extra into experimenting with texture than with taste, the third is your good match.

STYLECASTER | We Tried Pinterest's Most Popular Fireball Pumpkin Pie Recipes—These Were Our Favorites

// Insert Your Fb Pixel ID under.
fbq(‘init’, ‘1130306277008218’);
fbq(‘observe’, ‘PageView’);
(perform(d)var id=”facebook-jssdk”;if(!d.getElementById(id))var js=d.createElement(“script”),ref=d.getElementsByTagName(“script”)[0];js.id=id,js.async=true,js.src=”https://join.fb.web/en_US/all.js”,ref.parentNode.insertBefore(js,ref))(doc)

Supply hyperlink


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.