Use of ‘glen’ on a German whisky is just too Scottish, court docket laws

Use of 'glen' on a German whisky is too Scottish, court rules

It signifies that the Waldhorn Distillery, in Bergen close to Stuttgart must trade the title of its “Glen Buchenbach” whisky  – until the verdict is appealed.

The inclusion of the phrase “glen” – because of this valley in Gaelic – within the branding, the regional court docket dominated, may make customers consider it used to be produced in Scotland.

Scotch Whisky, considered one of Scotland’s largest exporters, which accounts for 20% of UK food and drinks exports, can best be offered within the EU whether it is if truth be told made in Scotland.

The case adopted a criticism through the Scotch Whisky Affiliation (SWA) a industry frame that represents Scottish whisky manufacturers. The Waldhorn distillery, led through Michael Klotz, now has a month to come to a decision whether or not to enchantment the verdict. If it does, the Hanseatic Upper Regional Court docket (OLG) must take care of the case.

The case had up to now been referred to the Ecu Court docket of Justice (ECJ) which clarifies issues of EU legislation.

The ECJ tested the case ultimate June however made no ultimate choice. The court docket had despatched the case again to the German judiciary, with some steerage.

SEE ALSO: Court docket to come to a decision if branding of Swabian whisky is just too Scottish

‘Essential to protective Scotland’s nationwide drink’

Alan Park, SWA Director of Criminal Affairs, mentioned the industry frame used to be “happy” with the court docket’s choice “that using glen on a German whisky is deceptive”.

“The SWA has constantly taken motion in our international markets to stop using Scottish indications of starting place on whisky which isn’t Scotch Whisky,” he added.

“That is essential to protective Scotland’s nationwide drink and is a deterrent to those that search to benefit from the standard popularity of Scotch Whisky and doubtlessly lie to customers.”

SEE ALSO: How smartly have you learnt German meals tradition?

“Courts throughout many jurisdictions have dominated that names, reminiscent of ‘Highland’ and ‘Glen’, and pictures, reminiscent of bagpipers, are so strongly related to Scotland and Scotch Whisky that their use on whisky of some other starting place is deceptive.

“Our case in opposition to Glen Buchenbach introduced transparent and compelling proof to the court docket that ‘glen’ is strongly related to Scotland and Scotch Whisky, and the one reason why to make use of ‘glen’ for a German whisky is on account of its undoubted affiliation with Scotch Whisky.”


The Klotz distillery used to be disenchanted with the decision. Consistent with surveys, few customers would have made an immediate connection between “glen” and “Scotch Whisky,” the attorneys for the distillery identified.

“With the similar reasoning, the SWA may declare virtually any Scottish-sounding time period reminiscent of ‘Mac’ or ‘Mary Stuart’ for itself,” legal professional Sven Mühlberger mentioned.

Klotz obviously states on his product that his Swabian unmarried malt whisky is produced in Berglen close to Stuttgart.

However the SWA had taken the tipple-maker to court docket over the label and its branding. The court docket fight has been ongoing since 2013, reported DPA.

The SWA had claimed using the phrase “glen” at the bottle gave consumers the affect that it used to be a Scottish whisky, a “Scotch”.

The time period “Scotch” is a ‘designation of starting place’ identify safe through the EU, very similar to “Champagne” or “Prosecco” for glowing wines from sure areas of France and Italy. “Glen” isn’t discussed within the laws.

Alternatively, the EU laws additionally stipulate that providers of spirits should no longer lie to their consumers as to the starting place in their merchandise. That is to offer protection to no longer best the manufacturers of the unique merchandise, however above all customers within the EU.

With 128 distilleries, Scotland has the perfect density of whisky distilleries on this planet. About 50 million bottles are exported to Germany.

!serve as(f,b,e,v,n,t,s)
if(f.fbq)go back;n=f.fbq=serve as()n.callMethod?
fbq(‘init’, ‘1765939700386961’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);

Supply hyperlink


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.