Is Astro’s A50 gaming headset price $200 greater than Logitech’s G433?

0
2
Is Astro's A50 gaming headset worth $200 more than Logitech's G433?


Maybe the very best half about Logitech, lately, is the variety of merchandise on provide at differing worth factors. After the corporate bought Astro Gaming final summer season, it added a high-end line of stellar gaming cans, rivaling anybody within the business, together with Razer, Turtle Seaside, and others.

And to indicate off its newfound vary in headset availability, the corporate despatched us two to play with: the corded Logitech G433, and Astro’s A50 Wi-fi. There’s rather a lot to like, however we’re going to pit the 2 in opposition to each other in a loss of life match of kinds as a substitute. To not spoil the ending, however Astro’s A50 is clearly the winner. However is it $200 higher than the G433? Not essentially.

Comfort

 

Comfort is a difficult subject. Is it extra handy to keep away from wired gadgets that would result in nasty accidents — for {hardware}, or consumer? Or is it extra handy to have a tool that by no means wants charged?

Proper. Comfort means various things to completely different individuals.

I sometimes favor cordless gadgets, and the A50 was no exception. The dearth of a twine dangling from my controller made it the clear-cut winner, however I’m additionally the man that remembers to cost it each night time after I’m finished taking part in. That stated, the battery life is great, providing about 11 hours of play time on common.

For people who would relatively not fear about conserving a tool charged — or the secondary base required to make use of the headset with the PS4 — the G433 might be your greatest wager.

The G433 comes with a typical 3.5mm headphone jack that plugs simply into any PS4 controller. Whereas the twine isn’t excellent, it’s definitely not as dangerous because it’d be in case you needed to plug into the PS4 itself, relatively than the controller.

Total, I may definitely reside with the twine. The truth is, I type of forgot about it solely after some time.

Sound

 

As sound goes, the A50 was once more the winner. However, as is hopefully fairly clear by anybody that’s ever learn a headphone evaluate, sound is tremendous subjective. I discovered the A50 to be stellar, however is it $200 higher than the G433? Completely not.

A few of this, in fact, might be because of the limitations of the PS4’s getting old structure, however the audio DSP is predicated on AMD’s TrueAudio know-how, which definitely shouldn’t be a lot of a bottleneck for nice headphones.

I discovered the G433, with its 7.1 encompass possibility, to be almost pretty much as good because the A50 by way of general sound high quality. Which means, whereas it was definitely missing in sure areas, it’s not sufficient to make me swap to the A50 if I used to be carrying the G433 on the time.

Gunshots, explosions, or a revving engine was pretty shut on each headsets, however the place the A50 actually shines is in delivering crisp, clear dialogue.

Consolation

Consolation is, once more, subjective. However I discovered the A50 to be extra snug over lengthy play classes than the G433. Each have outsized ear cups that get rid of some ear fatigue whereas carrying them, however the A50 provides a pleasant band on the high that helps disperse among the weight evenly throughout your head. Which means, you’re not getting that one spot on high of your head that’s shouldering the majority of the burden, like you’re with the G433.

The ear cups are additionally barely larger on the G433 than the A50, though I didn’t discover that to be a lot of a professional or con, only a model alternative that didn’t make a lot of a distinction by some means.

Options

 

The A50 gives 7.1 Dolby encompass, a state 15 hour battery life (we skilled round 11), a totally wi-fi design. Properly, a type of totally wi-fi design: you’ll nonetheless must plug the bottom unit into the again of the PS4 to transmit to the headphones.

The cans use 5 Ghz wi-fi know-how, which implies it does a reasonably good job of preventing by means of cluttered in-home airwaves to succeed in the headset with out a lot in the best way of interruption.

It’s received a flip-to-mute microphone that’s a stable characteristic addition — I play with out the microphone more often than not, however it was a pleasant characteristic to have the ability to simply flip it into place and begin speaking if I wanted it.

The G433 set is a bit missing in options, however does have the identical 7.1 encompass, solely with DTS Headphone:X as a substitute of Dolby. The web site claims spatial consciousness that locations you in the midst of the motion, though I didn’t discover that it labored all that properly, and I used to be nonetheless pretty confused at instances about which route sound was coming from if it wasn’t on to my proper or left.

The noise-cancelling increase microphone has a inbuilt pop filter, which is a bonus for readability and people difficult “P” and “S” sounds that always come throughout muddled or overly loud in voice chat.

Aesthetics

I used to be somewhat let down by the look of the G433. For a headset pretty much as good as this one, the supplies simply felt dated and relatively low cost.

The A50, however, appeared premium. It seemed overly “gamer” for me, with its multi-colored surfaces and industrial design, however for some that’s most likely a profit. Total, I definitely wasn’t embarrassed to put on them, but when they had been common function headphones they aren’t the kind I’d need to tackle an airplane — okay, perhaps if I had been a DJ.

Connectivity

Whereas it doesn’t have the standout options of the A50, you’ll be able to definitely make the argument that the G433 is the higher purchase by way of connectivity. I’m no fan of wires, however the advantage of the three.5mm jack is that it really works wherever: in my PC, pill, PS4, Xbox One, Nintendo Change… any gadget with a headphone jack, principally.

The A50 can’t make these claims, because it’s a one-trick pony. I’m advised it’ll work with my PS4 as designed, however with out forking over some additional money for an Xbox-specific base, I can solely get audio (no voice chat) if I wished to modify over to a different system. It does appear to work high quality on my PC, nonetheless.

Astro’s A50 additionally loses marks for its shoddy, at instances, connectivity with the PS4. I discover myself dropping out and in of video games, although solely briefly, a number of instances throughout a two to 3 hour session. Every time the audio drops it comes again shortly, averaging only a second or two of misplaced audio, however typically these seconds matter, and it’s irritating nonetheless.

Ultimate ideas

Whereas it’s troublesome to make the comparability between a $100 headset and a $300 headset, what I feel stunned me most by evaluating the 2 is how nice a price the G433, by Logitech, actually is. I nonetheless want the corporate had made some higher design choices, and maybe provided a tad extra polish on the cheap-ish finishes, however for $100, it’s exhausting to recommend a greater headset at this worth level.

As for the A50, properly that’s a bit extra difficult. It’s definitely nice to have a look at, and the audio actually is stellar. Nevertheless it’s in rarified air at $300, the kind of place inhabited by the best-of-the-best gaming headsets on provide. It’s definitely the higher headset of the 2. Nevertheless it needs to be for an additional $200, proper?

Is it price $300?

That’s questionable. For our cash we’d nonetheless go together with the Steelseries Arctis Professional Wi-fi for about $30 extra.



Supply hyperlink

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.